The plaintiff experienced a traumatic event, triggered by her boyfriend's inaction during a physical assault. The trauma of past domestic violence resurfaced, and her boyfriend's failure to protect her exacerbated her emotional distress. He knew about her past and should have been more sensitive and proactive.
While the boyfriend's inaction was insensitive, holding him solely responsible is an overreach. The assailant is the primary culprit, and the boyfriend's failure to act may stem from shock or fear, not necessarily a lack of love. The plaintiff needs therapy, not to scapegoat her boyfriend.
The boyfriend's inaction was a significant failure in his duty to protect his partner, especially given her history of abuse. However, the primary responsibility for the assault lies with the friend who initiated the physical contact. While the boyfriend's behavior was disappointing and warrants serious discussion and potential therapy, it does not equate to direct culpability for the assault itself.